MastaDon ✅ is a user on octodon.social. You can follow them or interact with them if you have an account anywhere in the fediverse. If you don't, you can sign up here.
MastaDon ✅ @soaklord

Wow... Just realized that Mastadon instances have the potential to become the ultimate echo chambers. I think that scares me to my core.

· Web · 0 · 0

@soaklord Can't be much worse than reddit though since it is so easy to see messages from other instances right?

@soaklord what makes it worse than any other website or forum?

@uve Because in a non-federated world (where federations can be chosen) there is no chance for a horrible toot going viral in a way that brings to light someone's idiocy. In fact, the idiocy can have a darwinian like idiocy evolution where only the most idiotic survive.

@soaklord Any site could end up in that situation.
if anything bc of federations more people will see content and more ideas can be exchanged.

@soaklord I've seen this a few times and I wonder why it is that we find this so frightening. The early internet was just a bunch of like-valued nerds, and we never had problems with being in chat rooms about our particular interests. Why are we so worried about a social experience being selective? We don't invite threatening jerks into our homes, why should we do it on our screens?

@soaklord (Honest question... I'm not trying to be contrary-- though I guess that does make me not an echo?)

@SuzanEraslan In the early days of the internet with ebaum's world and rotten.com and the like, there was an innocence (wrong word, perhaps naivety) that was present. Now the web can be a much darker place. It will be interesting to see how it plays out. I think you will see a divide in short order of instance mindsets. Federation moderation will become far more key than user moderation as this grows.

@SuzanEraslan With that said, I think that this will also allow for people to be the many faces they are to others. You can present your social.family instance to one group, your social.politics or interests or, creative thoughts to another all with your choice of instance.

@soaklord Someone said the other day that they are certain that the trolls and the Nazis will find their way in to start their own instances where "free speech is respected," but that that would actually be a good thing... Let them segregate themselves into their own basket and add those baskets to black lists for the better instances.

@soaklord We will have to choose our instances carefully.

@soaklord both Facebook and Twitter are echo chambers already. At less here if there is an echo chamber then it's explicit and can be broken/damper with federation to opposite view instance. the same can't be said about Facebook and Twitter