@kara I could spend hours looking at Jackson’s pictures. It’s a different beast, of course. But if a movie is just like the books, it wasn’t worth the effort. So I’m not opposed to different interpretations and I enjoy the variations. I played on the Elendor MUSH for a while and that was also very unlike the books. The point is not whether anybody likes it but whether we need permission in the first place. And I hate the begging and paying for permission.