Tremaine is a user on octodon.social. You can follow them or interact with them if you have an account anywhere in the fediverse. If you don't, you can sign up here.
Tremaine @Mainebot

Hey nerds I worked pretty hard on this,

medium.com/tootsuite/this-isnt

and I'm trying to help get more people on the platform. Maybe y'all want to read it? I am extremely vain but I think you'll agree with the premise.

· Web · 38 · 36

@Mainebot It got a few upvotes when I posted it on HN

@Mainebot It's a good article which summarizes the problem with algorithmic timelines well.

@Mainebot great piece. I'd "clap" but that would involve making a Medium account.

@Cybertrash that's ok, I'm trying to just get more people on Masto, so you can always just throw the link at people. Wrap it on a brick, toss it through a window.

@djsundog @Cybertrash

It's my hot new direct mail campaign tactic

@Mainebot Hey, it's great. I just read through it, and when I got to the sentence," That's why we need Mastodon" I was thoroughly expecting some points on why Mastodon is different from that status quo, and why you think Mastodon can be effective at all of the things other media platforms have botched. Just letting you know the feeling I had at the end there in case you want to explicitly tie some of that up at the end.

@Mainebot I find it a little ironic that it is published on Medium.

@Mainebot i totally missed this, and it's already SUPER late but i promise to read it first thing tomorrow

@nightpool hey, whenever you have time it's ok :)

@Mainebot it's a good article! it's a little light on details, but that's fine! it's a blog article, not a treatise or anything lol.

I think I take a little bit of an issue with the framing around a chronological feed—honestly, most people don't care if their posts are in order or not in order or whatever. they care about the *motive*. people *care* about the fact that their facebook feed serves facebook's interest, not theirs. they care about the fact that facebook has a stranglehold on all news media -

@Mainebot and they care about the fact that their posts could disappear at any time, if facebook or twitter or tumblr or instagram decide they're not worth the trouble. if an advertiser decides they need to "clean up" or "protect their brand".

or if they're embarrassing to facebook—then there's a real risk they could be cut off from their oral history and *the vast majority of social interaction on the internet*.

@Mainebot like, we talk a lot about the nazis on twitter but seriously compared to facebook twitter isn't even a thing! facebook is so so so big that it's hard to wrap your head around.

and these aren't abstract concepts. *everything* i listed has concrete, real examples i could list from just the past 12 months! it's wild. it's fucking wild.

@Mainebot and you definitely gesture towards a lot of that in your article, and its a really good article, but it feels weird to focus on the linear timeline as a lynchpin here. Id be happy with a open social media platform that showed me posts in a completely random order. hell i'd probably be pretty happy with a non-chronological one!

the more fundamental thing is how these corporations twist and our distort social spaces into a parody of themselves, centered around advertisers. it's downright dystopian

@nightpool

I agree with all your points, but I was constrained by the length. I'm thinking about a follow-up because it's worth expansion.

Also, it's hard to draw a direct comparison between Mastodon and Facebook, because fb is just... Feature complicated. A lot if different parts.