“There are many Hong Kongers and other smart people writing online who can explain the political context of the protests, the likelihood of intervention, and what this means in a deeper way. I am just a visitor who perhaps thinks too much about fish cakes when being tear gassed.”
Of course Maciej Cegłowski went to #HongKong protests and wrote a brilliant piece, with references to how the ’80s Soviet–American culture shock is as great as the 2010s America–HK one.
You know when you read about momentous events in history. D-Day—but also the Warsaw Uprising: events that the history books ex-post frame as “obviously” earth shattering, but also the ones books only casually mention because nothing really major resulted.
Watching the #HongKong situation these weeks has been a smorgasbord of nerve-racking breath-holding waiting to see whether this goes down as 1991-grade Soviet collapse event, or another of the many non-cigar close calls.
That precipice. 🤤!
Yes: since I learned the dynasty song in the HarvardX #China history course,
Shang Zhou Qin Han…
and studied the longevity and fall of other single-party states (Nazi, Soviet, Cambodia, Vietnam, Yugoslavia, etc.), my secret delight has been wondering what comes after the last verse of the song,
Yuan Ming Qing Republic,
When will Mao’s CCP go the way of the Shang and the Soviets, and what will come after? I’m sure it’ll be just as monumental a black swan 🦢!
"#China wants to eat Hong Kong. That is what these protests are about."
"The [protest] groups disagree on tactics, but are each committed to the principle that they will not allow themselves to be divided. There is immense tolerance of tactical differences that would fracture other movements." 😮
When this son of Soviet Poland says "that's when I understood the Hong Kongers may actually win", I'm like 😮😮😮?!!?
‘“The raptors followed us onto the other train. People were terrified. I saw a mother holding her two little daughters. They were all crying. I saw two young women who probably just came back from shopping or a night out because both were dressed in nice clothes. They were clinging to each other, huddled in a corner, crying. There were old people holding onto their shopping bags, shaking with fear.”’
#HongKong police brutality via Pinboard aka Maciej Cegłowski’s Twitter.
‘Ng saw police hit another young man in a white shirt on the head. Blood was pouring down his neck. “He just fell, and I didn’t see him move again.” They toppled another young man wearing black, beating him with batons and kicking him where he lay.’
@22 Yugoslavia....what a great comparison
@a_breakin_glass want to emphasize I’m not comparing anything to anything here!, just giving examples of diverse single-party states I’ve studied in school and on my own, and that inform me of some aspects of their collapse. Few parallels can be drawn! History is a good teacher—but it can only tell you what won’t happen, not what will.
The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!